BALKANS TO THE BALKAN NATIONS OR BALKANS TO THE EMPIRES: HOW TO ESTABLISH PEACE AND PROSPERITY IN THE REGION

Mile Bjelajac

Abstract

This paper within its limited length encompasses only basic framework for the understanding of this historically and currently well-known region. Writing and rewriting of its history is daily on agenda not only for the scholars, but think-tanks and politicians alike. Western approaches to the Balkans are not often scholarly. As some pointed out, we usually cope rather with the perceptions than profound, complex and above all comparative analyses. The latter ones would suggest that Balkan and its misfortunes are not something unique in the Europe or in the global history. The fragmentation, civil wars and violence have been part of the history of many other countries. Certainly, the Empires that dominated the region, were not only factor of stability, coexistence of different peoples, religions and customs but also factor of decline in economic prosperity, modernization, education, security at the time of their demise. The Balkans as we demonstrate in brief historical survey was the border land of the Empires but also of the religions. In spite of its local centers, small capitals, the area never had its own big center, actually the Balkans have had three, or nowadays more external capitals: Constantinople (Istanbul), Vienna, Venezia, Rome, Paris, Washington, Berlin, Moscow. They succeeded each other from the past to the present, and usually overlapped. These overlapping have caused frictions on the ground, even war crisis and mistrust among small Balkan states in modern times. From the experience of not only Serbian 19^th century politicians, they confront interference of the Great Powers in the Balkans by slogan “Balkans to the Balkan nations”. That is to say to find common ground of basic interests for peace and prosperity and whereby the union enough strong for deterrence. Yugoslavia as the legacy of the Serbian victory in 1918 and as the part of antifascist coalition at the end of WW II, embraced policy of peaceful coexistence and stability in the region for the almost seventy years. The dissolution or destruction of Yugoslavia, renewed “Eastern Question”, that is to say combat for the legacy of valuable region in terms of geopolitical importance and natural sources. All those emerging, greedy interests were carefully wrapped into sound, humanitarian and democratic seeking slogans. Not only extremely superior military power and doctrine demonstrated in Iraq 1991, but also exploit of the new phenomena- global (controlled) media, enabled pressure on small countries or different parties in conflict to obey what powers wanted. Those who created new world order after collapse of Soviet Union wanted firm dominance and control of the region, as well as boot on the ground. New emerging powers like Germany and Turkey, wanted they share to prove themselves as the great powers too. Both strongly interfered in the different phases of Yugoslav crisis and wars for succession. Russia and China became new players after the years of absences from the region. European Union did not show consistency and applied rather partial approach. It was due to disagreements within Union itself but also due to interference of U.S.A. EU has its own problems in economic transition, refugee and protracted economic crisis. EU countries felt boomerang impact from the sanctions imposed to Russia. All that could not contribute positively to further integration of the whole the Balkans into the Union. By applying recommended double standards, tricks and military force (see Robert Francis Cooper, The Breaking of Nations) against failed (or even rogue) states, there would be no permanent stability in this region but insecurity, corruption, quasi-democracy, oligarchs on one side and poverty on the other.

References

• Ahrens, Geert-Heinrich. 2007. Diplomacy on the Edge. Containment of Ethnic Conflict and the Minorities Working Group of the Conference of Yugoslavia. Washington: Woodrow Wilson Center Press, Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
• Avramovski Živko. 1986. Balkanska Antanta (1934-1940). Beograd: ISI.
• Bacevich, Andrew. 2020. The Age of Illusions. How America Squandered its Cold War Victory. NYC:Metropolitan Books.
• Bakić Hayden, Milica. 2006. Varijacije na temu “Balkan”. Beograd: Filip Višnjić, Beograd.
• Barker, Elisabeth. 1975. Britanska politika na Balkanu u II svjetskom ratu, Zagreb: Globus.
• Батаковић, Душан Т. (прир.). 1998. Савременици о Косову и Метохији 1852-1912. Београд: СКЗ.
• Bataković, Dušan T. (ed.). 2011. La Serbie et la France une alliance atypique, Relations politiques, economiques at culturelles. Belgrade: Institute des etudes balkaniques.
• Бјелајац, Миле. 2010. Дипломатија и војска, Србија и Југославијa 1901-1999, Београд: Медија центар Одбрана: Академија за дипломатију и безбедност.
• Bjelajac, Mile 2015. „War Aims and War Aims Discussions (South East Europe)”. In: 1914-1918 International Encyclopedia of the First World War (eds. Ute Daniel, Peter Gatrell, Oliver Janz, Heather Jones, Jennifer Keene, Alan Kramer, and Bill Nasson). Berlin: Freie Universität Berlin.
• Бјелајац, Миле. 2019. 1914-2014: Зашто ревизија? Мењање оцена о узроцима Првог води ревизији оцена о узроцима Другог светског рата. Београд: Прометеј.
• Бјелајац, Миле. 2019. „Прикривање и разоткривање правих разлога за рат 1999. на Косову и Метохији“. Политика националне безбедности, 1/2019.
• Bjelajac, Mile. 2019. „The Austro-Hungarian Creation of “Humanitarian” Pretext for the Planned Invasion of Serbia 1912-1913: Facts and Counter-facts“. Balkanica, L, 2019.
• Винавер, Вук. 1987. Светска екомоска криза у Подунављу и немачки продор 1929-1935. Београд: ИСИ.
• Влаховић, Бранко. 2014. Путин, Моћ Русије. Београд: Вукотић Медија.
• Ganzer Danijele. 2018. Protivzakoniti ratovi. Beograd: Laguna.
• Gerolimatos, Andre. 2001. The Balkan Wars. Myth, Reality, and the Eternal Conflict. Toronto: Stoddart.
• Doise Jean and Vaisse Maurice. 2015. Diplomatie et outil militaires, Politique etrangere de la France 1871-2015. Paris: Editions de Seuil.
• Ђурковић, Миша. 2015. Илузија Европске уније. Београд: Catena Mundi.
• Živojinović, Dragoljub. 1980. Vatikan, Srbija i stvaranje Jugoslovenske države 1914-1920. Beograd: NOLIT.
• Zametica, John. 2017. Folly and Malice. The Habsburg Empire, the Balkans and the Start of World War One. London: Shepheard Walwyn.
• Kagan, Donald. 1995. On the Origins of War and the Preservation of Peace. NYC: Anchor Books.
• Kennan, George F. 1993. The Other Balkan Wars. A 1913 Carnegie Endowment Inquiry in Retrospective with New Introduction and Reflections on the Present Conflict by George F. Kennan. Washington: Carnegie.
• Kennedy, Paul. 1989. The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers: Economic Change and Military Conflict from 1500 to 2000. NYC: Random House.
• Kisindžer, Henri. 1999. Diplomatija I-II. Beograd: Versalpres.
• Кљакић, Љубомир. 2011. Криза, корисни идиоти и колапс Србије. Београд: Печат: Фонд Слободан Јовановић.
• Lampe, John R. 2014. Balkans into Southeastern Europe, 1914-2014, A Century of War and Transition. NYC: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Lieven, Dominic. 2015. Towards the Flame. Empire, War and the End of Tsarist Russia. NYC: Penguin Random House.
• Миликић, М. и Рудић, С. (ур.). 2013. Балкански ратови 1912-1913: нова виђења и тумачења. Београд: Историјски институт: Институт за стратешке студије.
• Mitrović, Andrej. 1981. Prodor na Balkan, Srbija u planovima Austro-Ugarske I Nemačke 1908-1918. Beograd: NOLIT.
• McMeekin, Sean. 2010. The Berlin-Baghdad Express, The Ottoman Empire and Germany’s Bid for World Power, 1898-1918. NYC: Penguin Books.
• Нарочницка, Наталија. 2008. Русија и Руси у светској историји. Београд: СКЗ.
• Norris John. 2005. Collision Course. NATO, Russia and Kosovo. London: Praeger.
• Pavlović, Vojislav G. (ed.). 2014. Italy’s Balkan Strategies 19^th & 20^th Century. Belgrade: Institute for Balkan Studies of the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts.
• Pavlowitch, Stevan K. 1999. A History of the Balkans 1804 – 1945. London: Longman.
• Поповић, Никола Б. 2007. Србија и царска Русија. Београд: Службени гласник.
• Распоповић, Радослав. 1996. Дипломатија Црне Горе 1711-1918. Подгорица: Историјски институт Црне Горе, Београд: НИЦ „Војска“.
• Растовић, Александар. 2015. Енглези и Балкан 1837-1914. Београд: Завод за уџбенике.
• Ристић, Љубодраг П. 2014. Србија у Британској политици 1889-1903. Београд: Балканолошки институт САНУ.
• Симић, Предраг. 2008. Тито и НАТО. Успон и пад друге Југославије. Београд: Новости.
• Сладек, Здењек. 2019. Мала Антанта 1919-1938, Њене привредне, политичке и војне компоненте. Београд: Службени гласник.
• Stanković, Đorđe Đ. 1984. Nikola Pašić, Saveznici i stvaranje Jugoslavije. Beograd: NOLIT.
• Станковић, Ђорђе Ђ. 1995. Никола Пашић и Хрвати. Београд: БИГЗ.
• Танасковић, Дарко. 2010. Неоосманизам. Доктрина и спољнополитичка пракса. Београд: Службени гласник.
• Todorova, Marija. 1998. Imaginarni Balkan. Beograd: Biblioteka XX vek.
• Толева, Теодора. 2016. Утицај аустроугарске империје на стварање албанске нације 1896-1908. Београд: Филип Вишњић: Институт за еврипске студије.
• Tooze, Adam. 2014. The Deluge: The Great War, America and the Remaking Of the Global Order 1916-1931. NYC: Penguin Books.
• Ćorović, Vladimir. 2018. The Relations between Serbia and Austria-Hungary in the 20^th Century. Belgrade: Institute for Balkan studies.
• Ferguson, Niall. 2005. Colossus: The Rise and Fall of the American Empire. NYC: Penguin Books.
• Fišer, Fric. 2014. Posezanje za svetskom moći, – Politika ratnih ciljeva carske Nemačke 1914-1918. Beograd: Filip Višnjić.
• Frankopan, Piter. 2018. Novi putevi svile. Sadašnjost i budućnost sveta. Beograd: Laguna.
• Halperin M. and Scheffer D. 1992. Self-Determination in the New World Order. Washington: Carnegie Endowment Book.
• Hobsbaum, Erik. 2002. Doba ekstrema. Istorija kratkog dvedesetog veka 1914-1990. Beograd: Dereta.
• Cohen, Lenard J. 1995. Broken Bonds. Yugoslavia’s Disintegration and Balkan Politics in Transition. Boulder: Westview Press.
• Штрандман, Василиј Н. 2011. Балканске успомене, књ. 1. Београд: Жагор.
• Yavuz, Hakan M. and Sluglett, P. (eds.). 2011. War and Diplomacy, The Russo-Turkish War of 1877-1878 and the Treaty of Berlin. Salt Lake City: Utah University Press.
• White, John Albert. 1995. Transition to global rivalry. Alliance diplomacy and the Quadruple Entente, 1895-1907. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.